Red Roasted Potatoes

by Krystel on Oct 10, 2023 (updated Jul 3, 2025)

Crispy and Savory: Mastering Red Roasted Potatoes

Hey there! Let’s chat about a true kitchen classic: red roasted potatoes. These little gems are more than just a side dish; they’re the unsung heroes at our dinner tables. Think about it – they bring that crispy, savory perfection that pairs so perfectly with practically anything. Whether it’s a cozy family dinner or a special celebratory meal, mastering the art of making these potatoes can elevate your cooking game to new heights. Not only are they delightfully easy to prepare, with their crispy skin and fluffy interior, but they also have a knack for soaking up flavors, making them an absolute must-try in any food enthusiast’s repertoire. Their popularity isn’t a mystery – it’s a testament to how indispensable they’ve become in our culinary lives, from casual weeknights to festive gatherings.

Key Takeaways:

Red roasted potatoes are a versatile and beloved side dish, essential for both everyday meals and special occasions.
They offer a perfect blend of crispy skin and tender interior, easily absorbing a range of seasonings for flavorful results.
Mastering this simple recipe serves as a foundation for elevating your cooking, making it a cherished skill in the kitchen.

Choosing the Right Potatoes

When I dive into the kitchen to whip up a comforting batch of red roasted potatoes, I’ve got a little secret for getting them just right: it’s all about choosing the right potatoes. I always reach for small red potatoes or baby red potatoes. Why, you might wonder? Well, their thin skins, lower starch content, and sturdy structure make them perfect for roasting. They crisp up beautifully on the outside, while the inside stays delightfully creamy. Plus, picking potatoes of similar sizes is my little hack for ensuring they cook evenly – no one wants a mix of overcooked and undercooked potatoes on their plate.

Now, I’ve tinkered with russet and yellow potatoes in my time. While russets can give you that fluffy texture, perfect for a mash, and yellow potatoes offer a creamier bite for your potato salads, they just don’t hold up as well in the roasting pan. So, for that perfect side dish that’s sure to impress, stick to the small red variety. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

Essential Ingredients & Alternatives

Olive oil or butter: For a healthier twist, opt for olive oil. It brings a wonderful aroma and a crispy outer layer to your potatoes.
Small red potatoes or baby red potatoes: These are the stars of the show! Their lower starch content and thin skins make them perfect for roasting.
Garlic powder or minced garlic: Adjust based on your taste preference. If you’re not a fan of biting into minced garlic, the powder offers a milder option.
Italian seasoning, fresh rosemary, or fresh dill: Pick and choose or mix them up. Each of these brings a unique depth to the dish.
Black pepper and salt: Basics that bring out the best in the potatoes.
Parmesan cheese: Optional but highly recommended for that savory, cheesy finish.

Preparation Before Roasting

Hey there, fellow cooking enthusiasts! Today, I’m diving into the cozy world of red roasted potatoes, a dish that’s as comforting as a warm hug on a chilly evening. Let’s chat about prepping these beauties, shall we? First things first, I always kick things off by giving my small red potatoes a good wash. It’s like they’re getting ready for their spa day in the oven! After they’re squeaky clean, I cut them into large chunks. This step is crucial, folks—it’s all about ensuring each piece has enough room to breathe and roast to perfection on the baking sheet.

Now, before these potatoes get their tan in the oven, drying them thoroughly is my secret weapon for that irresistible crispy skin we all crave. I wrap them in a tea towel and give them a gentle pat, almost like I’m drying off a little puppy. Once they’re as dry as a sunny day in the desert, onto the sheet pan they go. But wait! I don’t just throw them on there. I lovingly grease the pan with a bit of olive oil or line it with parchment paper for a seamless, non-stick experience. This little prep talk ensures our potatoes are ready to face the heat and come out golden brown and delightful. Let’s get roasting!

Roasting Process Explained

Starting the perfect roast begins with cranking that oven up to a cozy 400°F. Now, I know what you’re thinking, “Isn’t that too high?” But trust me, for those little red potatoes to reach that golden brown nirvana, they need the heat. Here’s a trick I learned – cover them with foil for the first part of their journey. This is like giving them a little steam bath, ensuring they cook through evenly. Then, halfway, whip off the foil to let them crisp up. Make sure they’ve got their space, though; overcrowded potatoes are like wallflowers at a dance – they just won’t shine. My oven, well, she’s a bit temperamental, so check on yours and adjust the time if needed. Generally, we’re talking an hour from start to finish, flipping midway for that all-around crisp. It’s simple yet magical.

Tools For This Recipe

Buy Now →

Buy Now →

Buy Now →

Buy Now →

Customizations and Optional Add-ins

Now, who says red roasted potatoes have to be a one-flavor wonder? Not me, that’s for sure. Let’s sprinkle a little fun and customization into our baking tray. Start with the basics, then get adventurous.

Herb it up: Don’t shy away from tossing in different herbs. Maybe some fresh rosemary or dill? Each brings a distinct taste that transforms the ordinary into extraordinary.
Spice, spice, baby: A dash of chili powder can kick things up a notch. If you’re feeling bold, why not?
Greens for the win: Toss in fresh green beans halfway through. They roast up beautifully, adding a crispy contrast to your dish.
Garnish galore: Before you serve, sprinkle with fresh parsley. A small step for potatoes, a giant leap for potato-kind in terms of color and freshness.
The final touch: Lemon zest or a sprinkle of parmesan? It’s your canvas. These finishing touches can elevate your red roasted potatoes from side dish to star attraction.

Storing Leftovers

After you’ve enjoyed those crispy and savory red roasted potatoes, and find yourself with leftovers, here’s how to keep them just as delicious for next time. Always use an airtight container for storage; this is crucial in keeping your potatoes at their best. Pop them in the fridge, and they’ll keep beautifully. When you’re ready for round two, reheating them properly ensures they retain that texture we all love. If you’ve made a big batch, freezing is an option too. Just remember, when it’s time to enjoy them again, thawing correctly plays a big part in bringing back those perfect flavors. However, be mindful about where you store these gems. Avoid anywhere with too much moisture; it’s the nemesis of crispiness. Follow these simple tips, and your leftovers will be a hit, part two!

Serving Suggestions & Pairings

Oh, the joy of finding that perfect side dish to bring your meal from just okay to absolutely delightful! I can’t help but revel in the versatility and charm of red roasted potatoes. Whether you’re looking to add a crispy and savory touch to your dinner table or seeking that classic side that everyone adores, these little wonders do the trick. Imagine pairing them with classic proteins like a succulent roast chicken or a hearty beef steak; the possibilities are endless. Not stopping there, I’ve tucked them into vibrant salad bowls for a nutritiously satisfying lunch and even used them as a base for hearty breakfast hashes that start the day on the highest of notes. Let me tell you, incorporating red roasted potatoes into your meals not only rounds out the nutrition but significantly boosts meal satisfaction. Every bite into those crispy skins and tender insides is a reminder of how simple ingredients, when prepared with a bit of love and care, transform into something extraordinary.

End on a High Note

We’ve covered a lot, haven’t we? From picking the perfect small red potatoes with their lovely thin skins to achieving that golden brown crispy skin in the oven or air fryer, it’s been quite the journey. Remember, whether you’re using olive oil or splashing a bit of vegetable oil, the key is to give those potatoes enough space on the baking sheet—aiming for that single layer is crucial. And isn’t it amazing how a little garlic powder, black pepper, or a sprinkle of fresh herbs can transform a simple red potatoes recipe into a perfect side dish that complements just about any main dish?

I’m all for keeping things simple in the kitchen, and I hope you feel inspired to take these basics and make them your own. Don’t shy away from experimenting with different seasonings or tossing in some fresh green beans for an easy side dish that’s sure to impress. It’s all about finding the right amount of heat, the best spices that suit your palate, and maybe even discovering a new favorite way to enjoy this classic side dish. So here’s to lots of crispy, savory, and absolutely delightful red roasted potatoes in your cooking adventures ahead. Who knew something as humble as potatoes could bring so much joy to our tables?

5 from 2 reviews